Discipline (Church Discipline)

Heard in the wild

The longer version

What it means

Church discipline is what a church does when a member is in serious, ongoing sin and won't repent: sexual immorality, abuse, fraud, persistent divisiveness, abandoning the faith. The process, drawn from Matthew 18, goes in steps. First, a private conversation. If that's refused, a second conversation with one or two others. If that's refused, the matter goes to the church's leaders, and sometimes to the whole congregation. If the person still refuses to repent, they're removed from membership — historically called excommunication — and treated as an outsider, though still welcome to attend and still loved. The stated goal at every step is repentance and restoration; the process ends the moment the person turns.

That's the theory. In practice, it's rare, it's painful, and it's done well or badly depending on the church.

Why people say it

Christians practice discipline because Jesus described it, Paul commanded it, and the Reformed tradition counts it as a mark of a true church. The reasoning: love confronts; a church that ignores serious sin harms the sinner, the victims, and its own witness. The best defenders emphasize that discipline is for members who've committed to the church's standards, that it's slow and private as long as possible, and that its whole point is to bring someone back.

How to respond

If a church you attend announces that a member is under discipline, it's serious and the details are usually private; don't speculate. If you're the one under discipline, take it seriously, ask exactly what's expected, and — if it feels like control rather than care — get outside perspective from a pastor or counselor unconnected to the church. If a friend was hurt by church discipline, believe them; misuse is real. If you're a leader considering it, most who've done it well say: slowly, privately, humbly, and with the person's restoration as the only goal.

If you hear it in different churches

Baptist, Reformed, and conservative evangelical churches practice formal discipline and often name it in their covenants. Anabaptists (Amish, Mennonite) have "the ban" and shunning, the strictest form. Catholics have excommunication — rare, formal, and mostly for public offenses — and canonical penalties for clergy. Orthodox have exclusion from communion at the priest's discretion. Mainline Protestants rarely practice formal discipline. Pentecostal and non-denominational churches vary widely.

Where does “Discipline (Church Discipline)” come from?

Jesus lays out the steps in Matthew 18:15–17; Paul commands the Corinthians to remove a man in open sin (1 Corinthians 5) and, later, to welcome back one who repented (2 Corinthians 2). The early church had a formal penitential system for grave sins. Medieval excommunication became entangled with politics; the Reformers restored it as pastoral, and Calvin's Geneva made it central. Baptist and Congregational churches practiced discipline vigorously through the 1800s, then largely abandoned it in the twentieth century. The Reformed resurgence of the 1990s–2000s revived it, and high-profile misuses in the 2010s prompted renewed caution.

Good to know

You might also hear

Common questions